![]() |
On Friday, June 8, 1787,
Major Pierce Butler of South Carolina was alternately engaged in,
and bored by, the debates of the Constitutional Convention. While
delegates discussed whether smaller states would be oppressed by the
larger ones in a new government, Butler sketched out a scheme for
semi-proportional representation in the new legislature. At the top
of the page (when it is turned this way), Butler granted three votes
to each "large" state ("M" for Massachusetts, "P" for Pennsylvania,
and "V" for Virginia), along with two votes apiece for five
medium-sized states and one vote each for Delaware, Georgia, and
Rhode Island. After the bitterest fighting of the summer, the small
states won their point when the Convention gave each state the same
voting power in the future Senate. In the upper right-hand corner Major Butler also seems to have engaged in a financial calculation; since the English pound was the prevailing currency in the thirteen states, money was reckoned in pounds, shillings, and pence, as he has done. His expense account? |